像 Green Book 那樣的種族歧視情節，不是看了陳思銘今天那篇文章，也不知道原來在二十一世紀的香港地還會發生。

//兩個月前，我同另一位朋友 Jason 一齊光臨足球會。Jason 已婚，不過嗰日佢太太遲 D 來，咁 Jason 就拖住佢個兩歲細路到先喇，身邊有位菲律賓女士 Isabelle。

亦係在球會門外，同一位高級食 Q 大哥，急步走向 Jason 一眾人，黑起面，高聲向着 Isabelle呼喝 ：請你記住，我哋個會雖然俾僱傭入場，但任何賓妹唔可以為會員或賓客 perform duty。//

看完以上內容，其實我都半信半疑，所以立刻向同樣是足球會會員的朋友查證，很想知道今時今日的所謂私人會所是不是真的會有這樣的 by-laws。「係呀，佢哋畀工人姐姐入嚟嘅，但工人姐姐唔可以餵我小朋友食飯囉，因為工人姐姐唔可以喺個 club 裏面 perform duty 嘛。我瀨過嘢啦，啲職員真係會走埋嚟話我哋㗎，不過職員好禮貌嘅。」

咁係咪中國籍嘅所謂工人姐姐都唔可以 perform duty？

「應該就係喇，咁但係個 club 見到中國人唔會出聲啦，佢哋都唔會知嗰位係工人姐姐。」

你又知？

「試過啦，嗰陣請陪月嘛，陪月姨姨係中國人，喺個 club 裏面餵我小朋友，都冇人出聲。」

算唔算係種族歧視，冇會員出過聲？

「唔知有冇喎，不過可能 Football Club 高層要咁做都冇辦法呢。有啲高層都唔 buy 咁嘅 by-law 㗎，好似 Tony Sealy 咁，營運主管嚟㗎，真係有人情味，又多人服佢，可惜未坐正，話唔到事。」

人家放下兒女家庭，飄洋過海到香港工作，就算不獲得掌聲，至少應該換來尊重。如果真是有組織帶頭訂立一些奇形怪狀的規矩去刁難別人，影響人家的自尊心，實在是十萬個要不得。

地球很危險，不是因為有人做了不該做的事，而是有人做了不該做的事之後，沒有人出聲。

誰是誰非都好，必定要出聲。

【現場直播｜Live】 二零二零年度第六次評議會常務會議｜The 6th Ordinary Council Meeting

直播連結：https://youtu.be/2DInxku0_Ig

Date: 30th December 2020 (Wednesday)
Time: 14:00 –
Venue: Union Council Chamber UG201, Union Building

Agenda
0. Meeting call to order and sing the Union Song

Section A
1. To read out the correspondences
2. To receive maiden speeches of new Council member
3. To elect the Chairperson of Union Council
4. To receive and adopt the agenda
5. To receive and adopt the minutes of previous Meetings

Section B
1. To appoint members of Council Committees
2. To approve membership of the Council Secretariat, HKUSU Council, Session 2020
3. To appoint the Honorary Treasurer of the Union
4. Questions put to the Union Executives, other Councillors, other Official Observers, Council Committees, or Union sub-organisations
5. To receive the half-yearly reports of Union Executives, Session 2020
a. President of Cultural Association
6. To receive and adopt the report of Working Group of the Judicial Committee No.1
7. To receive the delegate report of the International Students’ Day Summit 2020
8. To discuss alleged infringement of Constitution by Japanese Society, A.A.H.K.U.S.U.
9. To discuss the arrangement of Annual Election 2021
10. To review affiliation applications
a. Calligraphy Society, HKUSU
11. To discuss amendments to the Union Council Election Regulation
12. To discuss possible violation of Council By-laws
13. To discuss possible violation of Council Resolution
14. To discuss possible invalidation of appointment of Returning Officer
15. To endorse statements issued by Council Committees
16. Any other business

【評議會新聞】評議會通過對本屆評議會違反學生會憲章遺憾動議

二零二零年度香港大學學生會評議會第十次緊急會議於十一月三十日晚上七時召開，並討論本屆評議會於過往會議中，涉嫌違反學生會憲章及評議會議事規則的事宜。

法律學會代表張敬生同學於會議開始前，向一眾評議員發放有關評議會違反學生會憲章及評議會議事規則一事的工作文件，內容主要包括：

一）由前校務委員會本科生代表兼二零一八年度大學事務秘書李梓成同學早前就評議會第五次常務會議所作出的投訴，包括
1）文學院學生會代表吳家齊同學作為會議召集人理應只受議事規則甲部第二條所賦予主席選出評議會主席的權力，吳是否能夠調動議程及擅自主持其他議案?

2）委任行政秘書馬浩天為署理評議會主席的議案可否以三分二之門檻投票，若不可，該投票結果是否仍成立？

3）委任法律學會代表張敬生同學為署理評議會主席的議案可否以三分二之門檻投票，若不可，該投票結果是否仍成立？

二）評議會涉嫌違反學生會憲章的事宜
內容引述多項學生會憲章[1][2][3]，探討評議會涉嫌違反學生會憲章的危機，並認為早前評議會會議中通過任命署理評議會主席直至下次會議開始或至特定時間做法違憲，包括本年度首個會議任命時任建築學會代表何梓駿為署理評議會主席。由於學生會憲章早已提供兩種情況，評議會應該優先以學生會憲章解決問題，而非以文學院代表作為會議召集人召開議會解決問題。

三）相關的解決方案，包括
1）假裝沒有事情發生，繼續進行這種違憲的做法。
2）注意這種違憲的做法，於未來會議中更正自己，以追認（ratify）評議會過往議案的方式處理過往會議中所犯的錯誤。
3）把本屆評議會的所有會議視作失效（be voided），並承擔沉重的後果，例如沒有選舉監察官（Returning Officer）於整個2020年度評議會中被委任，換言之任何選舉、常務投票（general polling）或任何屬會的常務會議均為無效。

四）評議會於第五次常務會議違反學生會憲章及評議會議事規則的事宜。

張於會議中解釋其工作文件。張先指出現時應詮釋的部分為學生會憲章，而並非議事規則。張認為過往任命署理主席的做法違憲，並指出現時情況有兩項相關條文：Article 5(c)[1] and 5(d)[2]。前者的字眼為「在他缺席之時」（in his absence）；後者則使用「未被填補或出現空缺」（being unfilled or falling vacant），意思為主席一職並不存在於評議會內。張表示評議會過往擴大學生會憲章的做法為不合理及不理想。

此外，張與其他評議員就其工作文件中所引用的英國國會例子討論。學生會外務副會長鄭凱盈質疑評議會及英國國會不能相提並論，張則指兩者的原則和理念相似，其引用目的為類比和參考。張認為評議會具「議會至上」（parliament supremacy）的功能，因此評議會應就其錯誤及違憲行為採取行動。張接著就學生會憲章的條文再作補充，表示憲章不會包含無用的字眼，並指責基於評議會對學生會憲章Article 5(d) 的無知，評議會濫用了議事規則。張最後建議評議會通過遺憾動議，並承認其違憲行為。

評議會於沒有反對下通過對本屆評議會於過往會議中違反學生會憲章第七節第五章[2]的遺憾動議。二零一九年度評議會主席溫銘賢同學指出本次是評議會史上第一次通過對自身的遺憾動議，並表示僅僅一項遺憾動議不足以讓評議會向全體會員交代，温亦認為本屆評議會應就此事作出後續行動，並建議評議會可追認過往的做法或作出解釋。

張認同評議會應追認早前所通過的議案，而評議會可向基本會員作出解釋。有關評議會程序上的錯誤，鄭提議填寫相關解決方法的備忘錄，以供屬會作參考。文化聯會會長朱卓楠同學認為評議會應先討論早前所通過的議案的效力（validity）應否被否決以及這些議案應否被視作失效。朱提出將本屆評議會通過的議案均視作失效。温指出朱的動議違反議事規則[3]，因此被當時主持會議的利銘澤堂宿生會代表郭永皓宣佈議案失效。社會科學學會代表羅希潼同學其後表示基於可行性的問題，評議會早前所通過的議案不應被視作失效，否則在場的評議員不再具評議員的身份，亦再沒有議案能獲通過。鄭就議案失效的原因再作補充，指出若所有獲通過的議案均被視作失效，將導致有效的評議員的數目少於15名，而由於法定人數不足，評議會會議將無法被召開。

其後，朱動議除本次會議的議案外，本屆評議會通過的所有議案均被視作失效。大學堂宿生會代表胡梓彥同學指若過往的會議被視作失效，第一位署理主席何梓駿的任命議案則屬無效，因此選舉監察官（Returning Officer）及部份評議員將同樣失去議席。議案最後以2票贊成、34票反對、0票棄權，未得三分之二之門檻被否決，期間只有動議與和議的朱及文化聯會代表二陳穎亨投下贊成票，其餘評議員包括校園傳媒代表均投下反對票。​

評議會其後於沒有反對下通過追認本屆評議會所通過的議案。李國賢堂學生會代表楊潔荔認為評議會有別於附屬學會，前者沒有更高的權力機關以監視自身，因此評議會應追認其議案。張則評議會更高的權力機關為全民投票及全民大會，惟召開全民投票及全民大會的可行性較低。

鄭指出評議會應交由修憲委員會討論追認的範圍。楊表示就遺憾動議一事，評議會應作具體行動向基本會員致歉。鄭提議由評議會事務委員會負責發出道歉信。郭總結評議會事務委員會將負責回應全體基本會員，而修憲委員會將負責討論有關追認的事宜。

評議會接著討論自身於第五次常務會議違反學生會憲章及評議會議事規則的事宜。文學院學生會代表吳家齊同學承認其過失，錯誤地使用了三分之二之門檻為委任行政秘書馬浩天為署理評議會主席的議案投票，但指出即使投票方式出錯，也不應視早前所通過的議案為失效。朱則表示於過往會議中，通過議案時沒有出現反對聲音，因此整個評議會應為其失誤負上責任。李建議評議會可先決定其投訴是否有效，再討論後續行動。李認為現時有足夠的後續行動以解決其投訴，若評議會認為李的投訴無效，評議會應就此事展開辯論。鄭認為李的投訴有效，而該投訴是按第五次常務會議的事務作出的，鄭提議評議會事務委員會可於道歉信中包含有關該投訴的解釋。張認為先前的討論已經回顧了這次評議會所犯下的錯誤，相信李的投訴將會納入評議會事務委員會即將處理的事項之中，希望李能夠放心。會議最後在未有任何評議員發言或作補充的情況下結束。

註
[1] : Article 5(c), Section VII, Union Constitution In the event that the Chairperson of the Union Council vacating the chair or in his absence, the Union Councillors present at the meeting may elect one among themselves to act as Chairperson of that particular meeting.

Article I, Section 5, Union Council By-laws He/she (Council Chairperson) shall convene Union Council Meetings and General Meetings and chair at these meetings, and shall act as commissioner for all General Pollings

Article 11(b), Section VII, Constitution Meeting of the Union Council shall be convened by the Chairperson of the Union Council at his/her initiative, or at the request of the President of the Union or any Union Councillor seconded by three Union Councillors

Order 2, Section E, Council Standing Order The Council Chairperson shall declare the opening, adjourning or closing of the meeting, direct the discussion, ensure observance of the Standing Orders and other statutory regulations governing procedure of the Council, accord the right to speak, put motions to the vote and declare decisions. He/She shall rule on points of order.

[2] : Article 5d, Section VII of the Union Constitution: "In the event that the Chairperson of the Union Council being unfilled or falling vacant, the Union Council shall appoint an acting Chairperson before a new Chairperson is elected at the subsequent Union Council Meeting."
[3] : Order 2, Section H, Standing Orders of HKUSU Council: “The resolution of the Council can only be rescinded, negatived, destroyed or amended with a two-thirds majority of the Councillors voting for it on subsequent meetings.”

法律學會代表張敬生工作文件： https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wN_AqiRo9xq2agEfN4OWIAYUkidKuerS/view?usp=drivesdk

二零二零年度第六次評議會常務會議｜The 6th Ordinary Council Meeting

Date: 30th December 2020 (Wednesday)
Time: 14:00 –
Venue: Union Council Chamber UG201, Union Building

Agenda
0. Meeting call to order and sing the Union Song

Section A
1. To read out the correspondences
2. To receive maiden speeches of new Council member
3. To elect the Chairperson of Union Council
4. To receive and adopt the agenda
5. To receive and adopt the minutes of previous Meetings

Section B
1. To discuss dispute between Karate Club, HKUSU and external body
2. To appoint members of Council Committees
a. Union Finance Committee
b. Union Elections Committee
c. Council Business Committee
d. University Affairs Committee
e. Current Affairs Committee
3. To approve membership of the Council Secretariat, HKUSU Council, Session 2020
4. To appoint the Honorary Treasurer of the Union
5. Questions put to the Union Executives, other Councillors, other Official Observers,
Council Committees, or Union sub-organisations
6. To receive the delegate report of the International Students’ Day Summit 2020
7. To discuss possible violation of Council By-laws
8. To receive the half-yearly reports of Union Executives, Session 2020
a. President of Cultural Association
9. To receive and adopt the report of Working Group of the Judicial Committee No.1
10. To discuss alleged infringement of Constitution by Japanese Society, A.A.H.K.U.S.U.
11. To discuss the arrangement of Annual Election 2021
12. To review affiliation applications
a. Calligraphy Society, HKUSU
13. To discuss amendments to the Union Council Election Regulation
14. To discuss possible violation of Council Resolution
15. To discuss possible invalidation of appointment of Returning Officer
16. To endorse statements issued by Council Committees
17. Any other business

Follow Us for Latest Update
--------------------------------
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/hkucampustv
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/campustv_hkusu
Twitter: https://twitter.com/campustv_hkusu

Our Website
--------------------------------
https://campustv.hkusu.hku.hk

【現場直播】【7th Ordinary Council Meeting, Session 2019 | 二零一九年度第七次評議會常務會議】

Agenda
0. Meeting call to order and sing the Union Song
Section A
1. To read out the correspondences
2. To receive maiden speeches of new Council members
3. To receive and adopt the agenda
4. To receive and adopt the minutes of previous Council Meetings
5. To report the motions carried by circulation
Section B
Section B
1. To appoint members and discuss matters related to Anti-Extradition Bill Publication Editorial Board, HKUSU Council, Session 2019
2. Questions put to the Union Executives, other Councillors, other Official Observers, Council Committees, or Union sub-organisations
3. To receive the Annual Report of Union Executives, Session 2018
a. President
b. Vice-President (External)
c. University Affairs Secretary
4. To receive the Annual Report of Council Standing Committees, Session 2018
a. University Affairs Committee
b. Current Affairs Committee
5. To appoint members of University Committees
6. To elect overseas conference delegates
7. To review the affiliation status of sub-organisations
8. To discuss the attendance of Council members
9. To amend the Judicial Procedure of the Union Council
10. To enact the Archive Regulation of the Union Council
11. To amend the By-laws of the Union Council
12. To discuss the arrangements of Annual Debate
13. To receive the report of Council Committees ad hoc
a. Union Journal Editorial Committee, HKUSU Council, Session 2017
(UJEC’17)
14. To receive the report of Annual Election Commission 2019, HKUSU Council, Session 2018
15. To receive the report of Orientation Affairs Committee, HKUSU Council, Session 2019
16. To receive the half-yearly reports of Campus Media, Session 2019
a. Undergrad, HKUSU
17. To receive the half-yearly reports of Union Executives, Session 2019
a. President (Acting)
b. Financial Secretary (Acting)
c. Student Welfare Secretary (Acting)
d. Administrative Secretary (Acting)
e. President of Independent Clubs Association
f. President of Cultural Association
18. To receive the half-yearly reports of Council Committees, Session 2019
a. Current Affairs Committee
b. University Affairs Committee
c. Union Elections Committee
d. Union Finance Committee
19. To endorse statements issued by Council Committees
20. Any Other Business

Campus TV, HKUSU Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/hkucampustv

Agenda

0. Meeting call to order and sing the Union Song

Section A
1. To read out the correspondences
2. To receive and adopt the agenda
3. To receive and adopt the minutes of previous Council Meetings
4. To report the motions carried by circulation

Section B
1. To discuss matters relating to the Class Boycott Campaign
2. To appoint members of Standing Committees
3. To nominate a Student Representative to the Selection Panel for Teaching Excellence Awards
4. To receive the report of Annual Election Commission 2019, HKUSU Council, Session 2018
5. To receive the report of conference delegates
a. 淡江大學學生會校際交流
6. To receive the annual reports of Union Executives, Session 2018
a. President
b. Vice-President (External)
c. University Affairs Secretary I
d. Student Welfare Secretary
7. To receive the annual reports of Council Committees, Session 2018
a. Current Affairs Committee
b. University Affairs Committee
8. To receive and adopt the reports of committees ad hoc
a. Union Journal Editorial Committee, HKUSU Council, Session 2017
b. Tendering Committee for Notebook Ownership Programme 2018, HKUSU Council, Session 2018
9. To amend the By-laws of the Union Council
10. To amend the Standing Orders of the Union Council
11. To appoint members and discuss matters related to Anti-Extradition Bill Publication
Editorial Board, HKUSU Council, Session 2019
12. To receive the half-yearly reports of Campus Media, Session 2019
a. Undergrad, HKUSU
b. Campus TV, HKUSU
13. To receive the half-yearly report of Popularly Elected Union Councillor I, Session 2019
14. To receive the half-yearly reports of Union Executives, Session 2019
a. President (Acting)
b. Financial Secretary (Acting)
c. Student Welfare Secretary (Acting)
d. Administrative Secretary (Acting)
15. To receive the half-yearly reports of Council Committees, Session 2019
a. Council Business Committee
b. Constitutional Review Committee
c. Current Affairs Committee
d. University Affairs Committee
e. Union Elections Committee
f. Union Finance Committee
16. To endorse statements issued by Council Committees
17. Any Other Business