毋忘五大訴求　公民抗命有理
—10‧20九龍遊行陳情書
（案件編號：DCCC 535/2020）

——————————————————
「毋忘初衷，活在愛和真實之中」
撐阿銘，即訂閱Patreon：
patreon.com/raphaelwong
—————————————————

胡法官雅文閣下：

　　2012年，我第一次站在法庭上承認違反「公安惡法」，述說對普選的盼望，批評公安惡法不義，並因公民抗命的緣故，甘心樂意接受刑罰。當年我說，如果小圈子選舉沒有被廢除，惡法沒有消失，我依然會一如故我，公民抗命，並且我相信將會有更多學生和市民加入這個行列。想不到時至今日，普選仍然遙遙無期，我亦再次被帶到法庭接受審判，但只是短短７年，已經有數十萬計的群眾公民抗命，反對暴政。今日，我承認違反「未經批准的政府」所訂立「未經批准的惡法」之下的「未經批准集結」罪，我不打算尋求法庭的憐憫，但請容許我佔用法庭些微時間陳情，讓法庭在判刑前有全面考慮。

暴力之濫觴

　　在整個反修例運動如火如荼之際，我正承擔另一宗公民抗命案件的刑責。雖然身在獄中，但仍然心繫手足。我在獄中電視機前見證6月9日、6月16日及8月18日三次百萬港人大遊行，幾多熱愛和平的港人冒天雨冒彈雨走上街頭，抗議不義惡法，今日關於10月20日的案件，亦是如此。可能有人會問，政府已在6月暫緩修例，更在9月正式撤回修例，我等仍然繼續示威，豈非無理取鬧？我相信法官閣下肯定聽過「遲來的正義並非正義」（Justice delayed is justice denied）這句格言。當過百萬群眾走上街頭，和平表達不滿的時候，林鄭政府沒有理睬，反而獨行獨斷，粗暴踐踏港人的意願，結果製造出後來連綿不絕的爭拗，甚至你死我活的對抗。經歷眾多衝突痛苦之後，所謂暫緩撤回，已經微不足道，我們只是更加清楚：沒有民主，就連基本人權都不會擁有！

　　在本案之中，雖然我們都沒有鼓動或作出暴力行為，但根據早前8‧18及10‧1兩宗案件，相信在控方及法庭眼中，案發當日的暴力事件仍然可以算在我們頭上，如此，我有必要問：如果香港有一個公平正義的普及選舉，人民可以在立法會直接否決他們不認可的法律，試問2019年的暴力衝突可以從何而來呢？如果我們眼見的暴力是如此十惡不赦，那麼我們又如何看待百萬人遊行後仍然堅持推行惡法的制度暴力呢？如果我們不能接受人民暴力反抗，那麼我們是否更加不能對更巨大更壓逼的制度暴力沈默不言？真正且經常發生的暴力，是漠視人民訴求的暴力，是踐踏人民意見的暴力，是剝奪人民表達權利的暴力。真正憎恨暴力，痛恨暴力的人，不可能一方面指摘暴力反抗，又容忍制度暴力。如果我需要承擔和平遊行引發出來的暴力事件的刑責，那麼誰應該承擔施政失敗所引發出來的社會騷亂的罪責呢？

社會之病根

　　對於法庭而言，可能2019年所發生的事情只是一場社會騷亂，務必追究違法者個人責任。然而，治亂治其本源，醫病醫其病根，我雖然公民抗命，刻意違法，控方把我帶上法庭，但我卻不應被理解為一個「犯罪個體」。2019年所發生的事情，並不是我一個人或我們這幾位被告可以促成，社會問題的癥結不是「犯罪份子」本身，而是「犯罪原因」。我明白「治亂世用重典」的道理，但如果「殺雞儆猴」是解決方法，就不會在2016年發生旺角騷亂及2017年上訴庭對示威者施以重刑後，2019年仍然會爆發出更大規模的暴力反抗。

如果不希望社會動亂，就必須正本清源，逐步落實「五大訴求」，從根本上改革，挽回民心。2019年反修例運動，其實只是2014年雨傘運動的延續而已，縱使法庭可能認為兩個運動皆是「一股歪風」所引起，但我必須澄清，兩個運動的核心就是追求民主普選，人民當家作主。在2019年11月24日區議會選舉這個最類近全民普選的選舉中，接近300萬人投票，民主派大勝，奪得17個區議會主導權，這就是整個反修例運動的民意，民意就是反對政府決策，反對制度暴力，反對推行惡法，不容爭辯，不辯自明。我們作為礦場裡的金絲雀，多次提醒政府撤回修法，並從根本上改革制度，而在10月20日的九龍遊行當然是反映民意的平台契機。如今，法庭對我們施加重刑，其實只不過是懲罰民意，將金絲雀困在鳥籠之內，甚至扼殺於鼓掌之中，窒礙表達自由。

堅持之重要

　　大運動過後的大鎮壓，使我們失去《蘋果日報》，失去教協，失去民陣，不少民主派領袖以及曾為運動付出的手足戰友都囚於獄中，不少曾經熱情投入運動的朋友亦因《國安法》的威脅轉為低調，新聞自由示威自由日漸萎縮，公民社會受到沈重打擊，我亦失去不少摯友，有感傷孤獨的時候，但我仍然相信，2019年香港人的信念，以及所展現人類的光輝持久未變。我不會忘記百萬人民冒雨捱熱抗拒暴政，抵制惡法，展現我們眾志成城；我不會忘記人潮紅海，讓道救護車，展現我們文明精神；我不會忘記年青志士直接行動反對苛政，捨身成仁，展現我們膽色勇氣；我不會忘記銀髮一族走上街頭保護年青人，展現我們彼此關懷；我不會忘記「五大訴求」，不會忘記2019年區議會選舉，展現我們有理有節。

　　法官閣下，我對於當日的所作所為，不感羞恥，毫無悔意。我能夠在出獄後與群眾同行一路，與戰友同繫一獄，實是莫大榮幸。若法治失去民主基石，將使法庭無奈地接受專制政權所訂立解釋的法律限制，隨時變成政治工具掃除異見，因此爭取民主普選，建設真正法治，追求公平正義，仍然是我的理想。在這條路上，如有必要，我仍然會公民抗命，正如終審法院海外非常任法官賀輔明（Lord Hoffmann）所言，發自良知的公民抗命有悠久及光榮的傳統，歷史將證明我們是正確的。我期望，曾與我一起遊行抗命的手足戰友要堅持信念，在艱難歲月裡毋忘初衷，活在愛和真實之中。

　　最後，如9年前一樣，我想借用美國民權領袖馬丁路德金牧師的一番話對我們的反對者說：「我們將以自己忍受苦難的能力，來較量你們製造苦難的能力。我們將用我們靈魂的力量，來抵禦你們物質的暴力。對我們做你們想做的事吧，我們仍然愛你們。我們不能憑良心服從你們不公正的法律，因為拒惡與為善一樣是道德責任。將我們送入監獄吧，我們仍然愛你們。」（We shall match your capacity to inflict suffering by our capacity to endure suffering. We shall meet your physical force with soul force. Do to us what you will, and we shall continue to love you. We cannot in all good conscience obey your unjust laws because noncooperation with evil is as much a moral obligation as is cooperation with good. Throw us in jail and we shall still love you.）

　　願慈愛的主耶穌賜我們平安，與我和我一家同在，與法官閣下同在，與香港人同在。沒有暴徒，只有暴政；五大訴求，缺一不可！願榮耀歸上帝，榮光歸人民！

第五被告
黃浩銘
二零二一年八月十九日

Lest we forget the five demands: civil disobedience is morally justified
- Statement on 10‧20 Kowloon Rally
(Case No.: DCCC 535/2020)

Your Honour Judge Woodcock

In 2012, I stood before the court and admitted to violating the "Public Security Evil Law". I expressed my hope for universal suffrage, criticized the evil law as unjust, and willingly accepted the penalty for civil disobedience. Back then, I said that if the small-circle election had not been abolished and the draconian law had not disappeared, I would still be as determined as I was, and I believe that more students and citizens would join this movement. Today, universal suffrage is still a long way off, and I have been brought before the court again for trial. But in just seven years, hundreds of thousands of people have already risen up in civil disobedience against tyranny. Today, I plead guilty to "unauthorised assembly" under an unapproved evil law enacted by an unauthorised government. I do not intend to seek the court's mercy, but please allow me to take up a little time in court to present my case so that the court can consider all aspects before sentencing me.

The roots of violence

At the time when the whole anti-extradition law movement was in full-swing, I was taking responsibility for another civil disobedience case. Although I was in prison, my heart was still with the people. I witnessed the three million-person rallies on 9 June, 16 June and 18 August on television in prison, when many peace-loving people took to the streets despite the rain and bullets, to protest against unjust laws. Some people may ask, "The Government has already suspended the legislative amendments in June and formally withdrew the bill in September, but we are still demonstrating, are we not being unreasonable?" I am sure your Honour has heard of the adage "Justice delayed is justice denied". When more than a million people took to the streets to express their discontent peacefully, the Lam administration ignored them and instead acted arbitrarily, brutally trampling on the wishes of the people of Hong Kong, resulting in endless arguments and even confrontations. After so many conflicts and painful experiences, the so-called moratorium is no longer meaningful. We only know better: without democracy, we cannot even have basic human rights!

In this case, although we did not instigate or commit acts of violence, I believe that in the eyes of the prosecution and the court, the violence on the day of the incident can still be counted against us, based on the August 18 and October 1 case. And now I must ask - If Hong Kong had a fair and just universal election, and the public could directly veto laws they did not approve of at the Legislative Council, then how could the violent clashes of 2019 have come about? If the violence we see is so heinous, how do we feel about the institutional violence that insists on the imposition of draconian laws even after millions of people have taken to the streets? If we cannot accept violent rebellion, how can we remain silent in the face of even greater and more oppressive institutional violence? The true and frequent violence is the kind of violence that ignores people's demands, that tramples on their opinions, that deprives them of their right to express themselves. People who truly hate violence and abhor it cannot accuse violent resistance on the one hand and tolerate institutional violence on the other. If I have to bear the criminal responsibility for the violence caused by the peaceful demonstration, then who should bear the criminal responsibility for the social unrest caused by failed administration?

The roots of society's problems

From a court's point of view, it may be that what happened in 2019 was just a series of social unrest, and that those who broke the law must be held personally accountable. What happened in 2019 was not something that I alone or the defendants could have made possible, and the crux of the social problem was not the 'criminals' but the 'causes of crime'. I understand the concept of " applying severe punishment to a troubled world", but if "decimation" was really the solution, there would not have been more violent rebellions in 2019 after the Mongkok "riot" in 2016 and the heavy sentences handed down to protesters by the Court of Appeal in 2017.

If we do not want social unrest, we must get to the root of the problem and implement the "five demands" step by step, so as to achieve fundamental reforms and win back the hearts of the people. 2019's anti-revision movement is indeed a continuation of 2014's Umbrella Movement, and even though the court may think that both movements are caused by a "perverse wind", I must clarify that the core of both movements is the pursuit of democracy and universal suffrage, and the people being the masters of their own house. In the District Council election on 24 November 2019, which is the closest thing to universal suffrage, nearly 3 million people voted, and the democratic camp won a huge victory, winning majority in 17 District Councils. As canaries in the monetary coal mine, we have repeatedly reminded the government to withdraw the extradition bill and fundamentally reform the system, and the march in Kowloon on 20 October was certainly an opportunity to reflect public opinion. Now, by imposing heavy penalties on us, the court is only punishing public opinion, trapping the canaries in a birdcage, or even stifling them in the palm of their hands, suffocating the freedom of expression.

The importance of persistence

As a result of the crackdown after the mass movement, we lost Apple Daily, the Hong Kong Professional Teachers' Union, and the Civil Human Rights Front. Many of our democratic leaders and comrades who had contributed to the movement were imprisoned, and many of our friends who had been passionately involved in the movement had been forced to lay low under the threat of the National Security Law. I still believe that the faith of Hong Kong people and the glory of humanity seen in 2019 will remain unchanged. I will never forget the millions of people who braved the rain and the heat to resist tyranny and evil laws, demonstrating our unity of purpose; I will never forget the crowds of people who gave way to ambulances, demonstrating our civility; I will never forget the young people who sacrificed their lives, demonstrating our courage and bravery; I will never forget the silver-haired who took to the streets to protect the youth, demonstrating our care for each other; I will never forget the "five demands" and the 2019 District Council election, demonstrating our rationality and decency.

Your Honour, I have nothing to be ashamed of and no remorse for what I did on that day. It is my great honour to be in prison with my comrades and to be able to walk with the public after my release. If the rule of law were to lose its democratic foundation, the courts would have no choice but to accept the legal restrictions set by the autocratic regime and become a political tool to eliminate dissent at any time. As Lord Hoffmann, a non-permanent overseas judge of the Court of Final Appeal, said, civil disobedience from the conscience has a long and honourable tradition, and history will prove us right. I hope that my comrades in arms who walked with me in protests will keep their faith and live in love and truth in the midst of this difficult time.

Finally, as I did nine years ago, I would like to say something to those who oppose us, borrowing the words of American civil rights leader Reverend Martin Luther King: "We shall match your capacity to inflict suffering by our capacity to endure suffering. We shall meet your physical force with soul force. Do to us what you will, and we shall continue to love you. We cannot in all good conscience obey your unjust laws because noncooperation with evil is as much a moral obligation as is cooperation with good. Throw us in jail and we shall still love you."

Peace be with me and my family, with Your Honour, and with the people of Hong Kong. There are no thugs, only tyranny; five demands, not one less! To god be the glory and to people be the glory!

The Fifth Defendant
Wong Ho Ming
19 August 2021

經常出街飲飲食食嘅我
最鍾意去食 #放題、 #打邊爐🍲 好Heavy嘅嘢
加上最近 #社會疫情緊張
飲食習慣多肉少菜
以及生活壓力導致有 #便秘 的問題
搞到肚仔都脹晒
谷住谷住好唔舒服
去便便都唔順暢 😖

最近 卡士蘭 的 #益生菌產品
【 #活腸纖腰瘦】
就幫到我解決以上問題
達致「 #先排毒． #後纖腰」的功效
治標治本，不會有副作用
當中更採用 #法國健康瘦身科技
更加入益生菌新配方
幫助消滯和清宿便

最特別嘅係【 活腸纖腰瘦】更有三款服用方法
有 #自然排毒、 #美肌、 #快速瘦身 等食法功效
簡直就啱晒我嘅身體需要‼️

⊰⊹════════════════⊹⊱
✎食後感 ：

【 #卡士蘭活腸纖腰瘦 】
✨平時着貼身衫個肚仔會突出嚟好礙眼
所以我嘅目標係想快速瘦身！
最近keep住每日食4-8粒
連續食咗一段時間已經有效果了
發現 #肚仔細咗平坦咗
個人輕飄飄左
仲可以舒緩食完飯 #飽滯 的情況添
成身都冇咁水腫
不過最重要係 #腸胃消化 及 #排便 比以前 #暢順 左
便秘情況有所改善！

==============================
🔎產品資料:
「 #卡士蘭活腸纖腰瘦+益菌」
🌐 https://www.nupharmonline.com/product-page/bio-hygiafit

🔹🔸🔹🔸🔹🔸🔹🔸🔹🔸🔹🔸🔹🔸
Nu Pharm 卡士蘭
#卡士蘭 #活腸纖腰瘦 #減肥 #瘦身 #Healthyproduct #極力推介 #美評家Tachoi #tachoi #hkbeauty #beauty #beautykol #beautyinfluencer #hkinfluencer

#EZTALK #你不知道的美國大小事
#打開看全文學更多

這回的🇺🇸美國大小事要來學一個非常好用的諺語🤣🤣
大家應該多少都有在被子裡不小心放屁臭到室友的經驗吧🤭
英文也有專門的諺語可以表達這件事👉 a Dutch oven
至於要怎麼使用呢？跟Libby一起看下去吧！

#好孩子不要學喔
--
If someone told you a woman had a bun in the oven, you may think it means she’s in the kitchen baking. But you’d be wrong. 1⃣Saying someone “has a bun in the oven” is actually a humorous way of saying that they’re pregnant. Ex: I heard a rumor that Kathy has a bun in the oven.
如果有人跟你說有位女性的烤箱裡有麵包，你大概會以為這女性在烤東西，不過這是誤會一場。說某人 has a bun on the oven，其實是詼諧表達她懷孕了。如：I heard a rumor that Kathy has a bun in the oven.（我聽說凱西懷孕了。）

And let’s end with another humorous one. 2⃣ A Dutch oven is a type of heavy pot used for making stews and casseroles, but it also has another meaning: farting when you’re in bed with someone and then pulling the covers over their head! Ex: Brian was acting like a jerk, so I got back at him with a Dutch oven.
最後再介紹另一個詼諧的用法。「Dutch oven 荷蘭烤箱」是用來製作燉菜和砂鍋菜的重型鍋，不過它還有另一種含義：「蓋被子放屁」，你跟某人躺在床上時突然放屁，然後還將被子蓋在他頭上！如：Brian was acting like a jerk, so I got back at him with a Dutch oven.（我用蓋被子放屁一招回敬布萊恩這混蛋。）

--
🔔 按下「搶先看」，每週五【美國大小事】，由 Judd 編審分享最即時美國新鮮事！想知道更多美國文化，請看 👉 http://bit.ly/EZTalk嚴選

週二、週四、週日 晚上9:00PM上新影片喔！
訂閱我的頻道 ➡️ http://bit.ly/nancytsaiyoutube
別忘了把「🔔」打開喔❤️

♥More information about this video ♥
Heavy Rotation 眉彩膠筆
KATE 3D造型眉彩餅
EXCEL 四色眼影 #SR05
MAYBELLINE x GIGI HADID 聯名款訂製眼彩盤 #GG15
PONY x MEMEBOX 眼影盤 #GLAM2
1028 絲滑控暈 暹羅貓眼線膠筆#01
1028 飛激長瞬翹防水睫毛膏
Maybelline 挺飛翹纖長防水睫毛膏
KISS ME 新翹力纖長防水睫毛膏
MAYBELLINE 超激細抗暈眼線液抗手震版
Physicians Formula butter bronzer #PF10598
EXCEL 漸層塑型腮紅 ＃01晨曦玫瑰
wet n wild 光采煥顏極光打亮粉餅
LOREAL 持色印記空氣吻唇露＃116試探
LOREAL 絕對情迷鏡面唇膏
LOREAL 奢華皮革訂製唇膏
LOREAL 3D玩色精油唇萃
CANMAKE 全方位遮瑕組
AB 上妝專用雙眼皮貼(膚色)-蝴蝶版
wet n wild 叛逆玫瑰蓬蓬暈染刷
wet n wild 叛逆玫瑰蓬蓬腮紅刷

📷 Camera：Canon G7 X Mark II http://bit.ly/2H4Fbgi
📹 Edited using Adobe Premiere
🎵Music：Young Stupid and in Love - Wildflowers

5種美容油用法 & 9瓶專櫃美容油評比！9 Beauty Oils Review & What's best for your skin type? https://reurl.cc/1nbl8
10瓶最愛的香水們 My Top 10 Favorite Perfumes https://reurl.cc/Kyl2q
Contouring Product Review 愛用修容產品分享 https://reurl.cc/pqvX8

♥徵求中英文字幕 Subtitle Wanted♥

上字幕教學➛ https://goo.gl/iURCeD (頁面裡有影片教學)
如果你有提交字幕, 麻煩來信nancy_blogger@hotmail.com 通知我～第一位完成的人我會寄送小禮物給你喔！

More Nancy over here 👇👇👇
📌W E B S I T E ➳ http://www.ksnancy.com
📌I N S T A G R A M 🔍 ntsai25
📌F A C E B O O K➳ https://www.facebook.com/ntsai25/

✉️ Business Inquiries please contact Henry at 『 hi@madebydys.com 』



🚩This Video is NOT sponsored.

係時候同大家分享我既畫眉心得，今條片會將平時無喺妝片詳細講既畫眉步驟；而且會同大家分析返眉筆眉粉眉gel既好處壞處+用途添???

大家睇完片記得去Facebook Page玩埋GIVEAWAY呀??
有機會贏走精美實用既眉妝產品架?????
(http://www.heavyrotation.hk)
－－－－－－－－－－－－－－

☆Find ME on Facebook -
https://www.facebook.com/bithialam.b
☆Find ME on Youtube - Bithia Lam
☆Find ME on Instagram - bithialam



This video is sponsored by Heavy Rotation.
This video was directed and edited by Bithia Lam.

出國趕時間怎麼辦？教妳們快速有效妝前保養+只用三樣產品完成全臉彩妝的小技巧！
這次去了峇里島走走放鬆 回來以後就像充飽電一樣 整個人都有精神了
影片也走一個舒服的路線 讓大家一起感受度假氣息
雖然是合作影片 但還是能讓大家在影片中學到不一樣的技巧
不管是妝前的快速補水術或是一物多用的化妝術
這些小技巧都非常實用 而且也不只是出國才可以用
平常趕時間的時候也可以這樣做～
明天就試試看吧！

是說本來要在這支影片之前先上一隻超好看的主題式穿搭影片
但是因為難度太高了 一直卡關覺得剪不出自己想要的感覺
於是就先上了這隻
穿搭影片還請大家等等我呀 一定非常精彩的～～

::Products List
►Lancôme蘭蔻 超進化肌因賦活露
清爽好吸收的質地 用法也非常多 它可以當作：

☑️基礎精華液
☑️前導精華 使用小黑瓶後再使用其餘精華液 可以加倍後續產品吸收力
☑️加入化妝水濕敷 深層修復保濕
☑️隔天有重要場合時更可以在面膜前使用 讓面膜更有效
☑️也可加入底妝 幫助底妝更服貼透亮
那影片中是示範的是快速保養法～
先加入化妝水濕敷 再使用化妝棉畫圈擦拭去除老廢角質
最後輕拍進肌膚完成快速保養
但平常使用的時候就當作一般精華液使用就好囉
或是小黑瓶之後再使用其餘精華液加強保養～非常多用！

►Lancôme蘭蔻 超進化肌因亮眼精粹
來教大家按摩小訣竅來對付拋拋眼！
首先先在瓶口旋轉取適量精華
『眼下畫圈圈』先使用畫圈的方式 輕輕的從眼頭往眼尾慢慢畫圈按摩
『撫紋小閃電』眼尾容易產生細紋 以小閃電的手勢按摩
『穴道深按摩』眼周穴道部分也別忘記
『byebye拋拋眼』最後使用冰珠輕輕的來回按摩眼周消除水腫 再使用指腹輕輕按摩幫助吸收
剩餘的精華液也可以用來按摩法令紋哦～

More👉🏻 https://goo.gl/dHswQh

►Revlon露華濃 超持色清透粉底液 #110
►Revlon露華濃 HD魅惑晶漾唇膏 #760
►KISSME花漾美姬 Heavy Rotation眉彩膠筆
這隻眉筆是眉膠質地 相對也比較持妝
也因為本身就有說可以眉毛跟眼線兩用 一般的眉筆不一定有辦法做到這樣哦 所以要是想挑兩用的話記得挑選一下
►KISSME花漾美姬 瞬翹自然捲防水睫毛膏 #玫瑰棕
這款顏色是漂亮的咖啡色 但跟正常版的比起來好像較容易垂

::WHAT I WORE
洋裝 Zalora
封面綠上衣 yve
http://yve.meepshop.com/product/59365e872a36cdd45a838852/
帽子 E.s boutique
https://www.facebook.com/E.SY8521310261/?fref=ts

::Music
https://soundcloud.com/jenisus/michael-giacchino-married-life-number-ii-jeriztiction-remix

〖Sponsored Video ::合作影片:: 〗

🌵🌵徵求中英文字幕 讓世界上更多人看見不同的分享🌵🌵
上字幕教學➜ https://goo.gl/NeUOlo
♡要是有好心人提供的字幕審核成功了 拜託請mail給我 我會邊哽咽邊寫上感謝卡一張與小禮物送到你家感謝你的♡
沒收到訊息我也會默默在心中一直幫你們祈禱事業順心平安快樂的哈哈哈哈哈哈
------------------------
FOLLOW ME ON

臉書粉絲頁::FANPAGE//
https://www.facebook.com/cc.chichiii/
::Instagram//
https://www.instagram.com/tickinaway/

#合作相關請聯繫 ::Contact
she8111@gmail.com