[爆卦]Of which whose是什麼?優點缺點精華區懶人包

為什麼這篇Of which whose鄉民發文收入到精華區:因為在Of which whose這個討論話題中,有許多相關的文章在討論,這篇最有參考價值!作者togs (= =")看板Eng-Class標題[文法] whose = the N o...






在文法書上有讀到這一句: whose N = the N of which

I like this book, the contents of which are fascinating.

於是想請教

whose N = the N of whom 這樣的句子正確否? (或是台灣多數認為錯誤或沒提到)

例如

I like John, the father of whom is a doctor.



(以下有個人綜合文法書後得到的看法



在賴世雄的<實用英文文法>書中第150頁提到,

"whose除可代替人以外,亦可代替物。唯代替物時 whose + n = the n of which"

換言之,這本書沒提到是否 whose + n = the n of whom

網路上有看見有人說到 whose + n = the n of whom 這樣的文法

而我用google查詢時,發現以下例句:

1. Her slave girl gave birth to a son, the father of whom is Jacob her

own husband

2. In May, 1997, Kent, Washington, elementary school teacher Mary Kay

LeTourneau, 35, gave birth to a baby girl, the father of whom is one of

her sixth-graders.

3. The cause of this quarrel was undoubtedly a child, the father of whom

is said to be Louis Kircher.

因此應該是有這樣的規則 whose n = the n of whom

不過目前手邊只有2本文法書

沒看見書上面提到,不太確定於是上來請教一下前輩們

謝謝





--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 59.113.208.125
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1443143828.A.00B.html
tyytt: 當然是可以那麼寫 09/25 21:16
tyytt: 不過人通常直接's就好,不需要the N of吧(? 09/25 21:19
tyytt: 然後看著看著想問第一個例句如果這樣寫有沒有問題,總覺得 09/25 21:21
tyytt: 念起來怪怪的I like the book which the content of... 09/25 21:21
togs: 感謝^^ 09/25 21:33
tyytt: 啊,對了不知道會不會被誤會,我是想說不知道寫成我後面打 09/26 16:03
tyytt: 的那樣有沒有問題 09/26 16:03

你可能也想看看

搜尋相關網站