[爆卦]what's the matter回答是什麼?優點缺點精華區懶人包

為什麼這篇what's the matter回答鄉民發文收入到精華區:因為在what's the matter回答這個討論話題中,有許多相關的文章在討論,這篇最有參考價值!作者scju (QQ)看板Eng-Class標題Re: [請益] wh開頭疑問的文法問題時間Mon ...


※ 引述《DreamerSun (都利姆桑)》之銘言:
: 前輩好!
: 小弟最近對於以下文法卡好久,一直想不通,
: A) I will show him who is the boss.
: B) I don't know who he is.
: 請問這兩句 who 後面的動詞位置不一樣的原因是?
: 為何 A) 不是 who the boss is?
: 謝謝大家!

可以直接看上色圖片版https://i.imgur.com/tVl72P0.jpg

因為懶得在BBS裡上色XD

以下是文字版
----
A) I will show him who is the boss.
B) I don't know who he is.

1.這兩句的都是名詞子句。

2. I will show him who is the boss.這句後面的who is the boss並沒有倒裝,因為
who本來就是主詞,誠如s831111所說的:
問:Who(主詞)is the boss?
答:Tom(主詞)is the boss.
----

參考
Practical English Usage 3rd. 278.7

Questions beginning "who/what/which + be" can ask for a subject or a
complement. Compare:
以who ;what ; which+ be 開頭的疑問句可就主語或補語進行提問。試比較:

Who is the best player here? 誰是這兒最好的選手?
(This asks for a subject: a possible answer is John is the best player here.)
(這是就主語進行提問:可能的回答是John is the best player here)

What is the time?
(This asks for a complement: a possible answer is The time is 4.30, NOT 4.30
is the time.)
(這是就補語進行提問:可能的回答是The time is 4.30,不能說:4.30 is the time.)

When we report the first kind of question (where "who/what/which + be" asks for
a subject), two word orders are possible.
在轉述第一種疑問句(這裏的who / what / which + be 就主語進行提問)時,有兩種可
用的詞序。

DIRECT:
Who's the best player here?

INDIRECT:
She asked me who was the best player.
She asked me who the best player was.

DIRECT:
What's the matter?

INDIRECT:
I asked what was the matter.
I asked what the matter was.

DIRECT:
Which is my seat?

INDIRECT:
She wondered which was her seat.
She wondered which her seat was.

This does not happen when "who/what/which" asks for a complement.
當who/what/which 就補語進行提問時,則只能有一種語序:

DIRECT:
What's the time?

INDIRECT:
She asked what the time was. (NOT USUALLY She asked what was the time.)
(通常不能說:She asked what was the time.)
----
回到本題:

※I will show him who is the boss.

這句的問句是who is the boss? 明顯問的是「問句中的主詞/主語who」,回答可能是
Tom (is the boss.)(因為這個問句中的主詞在回答時也是主詞,因此寫成間接問句時,
語序就不需要變動,本來就是「主詞+動詞」的順序。)

不過若照Practical English Usage的說法,問「主詞/主語」時,可以有兩種間接問句寫
法:
I will show him who is the boss.
I will show him who the boss is.

※I don't know who he is.

這句的問句是Who is he? 問的是「問句中的主詞補語he」,回答可能是He is the
boss. (因為這個問句中的主詞補語he,在回答時變成主詞了,因此寫成間接問句時,語
序需要變動,要把he放到is前面,寫成I don't know who he is.這樣才是「主詞+動詞」
的順序,而who在這裡就是名詞子句連接詞)

照Practical English Usage的說法,問主詞補語時只能有一種寫法:I don't know who
he is.

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 1.169.68.139 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Eng-Class/M.1563120210.A.6B6.html
DreamerSun: 謝謝您,我消化一下。很豐富的內容 感謝您的熱心! 07/15 00:53

你可能也想看看

搜尋相關網站